As soon as President Bush signs the Detainee bill just passed by the Senate, this will now be legal in the United States:
Said thinks of himself as a loyal American. He moved to the United States as a child from North Africa. He married an American woman and has three children. He runs a small business. He speaks with a Midwestern accent. There was a time, of course, when he was an angry young man, and like many angry young men he ran with the wrong crowd as a young adult. He went to a few meetings with some Muslim radicals, one of whom ended up going to Afghanistan to fight the Soviets. And he met a few men with whom he stays in contact; they are nice enough people when they aren’t talking about religion or politics. They even got him in touch with some charities that give money to Palestinian families. He supports the Palestinian people and opposes the Iraq War, but he is a pacifist at heart and has argued repeatedly with his more radical Muslim friends about the use of suicide bombings and terrorism. As Said has repeatedly said, the ends does not justify the means.
Unfortunately for Said, those connections to radical Islam have put him on an FBI watch list. Eventually, the FBI discovers that one of Said’s old acquaintances has started taking flying lessons. They decide to take action. Said is rounded up with a large number of other people as “enemy combatants”. In other words, the FBI breaks into his house in the middle of the night and arrests him. No warrant for his arrest was ever issued; in fact, his phone has been tapped for months and no warrant for that was ever issued either. He is sent to a military installation to be held. His family is never told where he went, and the FBI will not even confirm that they have arrested him. Said never sees a lawyer or a judge. In the meantime, the President has decided to define torture to exclude only actions that cause permanent physical harm. That definition is classified so the administration continues to assert that they have the utmost respect for human dignity. Said knows better. He is deprived of sleep for weeks at a time, and forced to stand barefoot on a concrete floor for hours at a time. He has no knowledge of the passing of time. And he is forcefully interrogated, using waterboarding techniques and electrodes. He knows nothing, and tells them that. They don’t believe him. Eventually he starts making stuff up, but it is too far-fetched. They still don’t believe him. Six months later the government releases him, weakened and mentally scarred, to go back to his family. No explanation, apology, or compensation is given.
That is a fictional account. But as of today it could happen. And the government would have broken no laws. All because we are afraid of attacks that haven’t happened, and therefore want to give more power to an incompetent administration and more moral authority to a group of people that deserve none.
God bless America, land of the free and home of the brave. Or not.
Recent Comments